Lacelle D, Radtke K, Clark ID, Fisher D, Lauriol B, Utting N, Whyte LG. 2011. Geomicrobiology and occluded O2-CO2-Ar gas analyses provide evidence of microbial respiration in ancient terrestrial ground ice. Earth and Planetary Science Letters 306: 46-54.
These authors compared the gas composition of ice from massive ground ice bodies (e.g. 30 000-year-old buried snowbanks) to atmospheric gas concentrations and gas contents from glacial ice. They also cultivated some microorganisms collected from within the ice, and used some non-culture-dependent methods to examine the diversity of those organisms.
Loss of O2, as determined by comparison of the ratio of O2 to Ar in samples, as well as changes to the 13C-CO2 contents indicate heterotrophic microbial activity in the ice, most likely by organisms living in high-salt brine channels in cracks in the ice, using dissolved organic carbon as both energy and C source.
This paper provides an overview of methods for extracting and measuring the gases trapped in microscopic bubbles in permafrost and ground ice, as well as interesting findings about microbial activities.
Showing posts with label Polar Science. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Polar Science. Show all posts
Thursday, August 25, 2011
Lacelle et al. 2008
Lacelle D, Juneau V, Pellerin A, Lauriol B, Clark ID. 2008. Weathering regime and geochemical conditions in a polar desert environment, Haughton impact structure region, Devon Island, Canada. Canadian Journal of Earth Science 45: 1139-1157.
These authors examined the soils and waters near the Haughton crater on Devon Island, to determine the importance of chemical and mechanical weathering in this polar desert environment. They examined dissolved material in streams, lakes, snow, and groundwaters, and the size distribution, shape, and chemical composition of particles from soils in several different local landforms and parent materials.
Despite low temperatures, low precipitation, and very low vegetation presence, significant chemical weathering was found. Signs of chemical weathering, rather than mechanical, include rounded surfaces and pits in sand particles and the concentrations of Ca2+, Mg2+, and HCO3- in waters. Signs of mechanical weathering were also found, including sharp fracture lines in particles.
A gradient of increasing chemical weathering and decreasing mechanical weathering was found from the surface to the permafrost table. Thermal buffering reduces the frequency of frost-driven forces and thermal expansion from daily at the surface to annually at the permafrost table. The permafrost acts as a barrier to water movement, creating relatively wet condtions at depth that allow aqueous chemistry including the dissolution of dolomite to proceed.
These authors examined the soils and waters near the Haughton crater on Devon Island, to determine the importance of chemical and mechanical weathering in this polar desert environment. They examined dissolved material in streams, lakes, snow, and groundwaters, and the size distribution, shape, and chemical composition of particles from soils in several different local landforms and parent materials.
Despite low temperatures, low precipitation, and very low vegetation presence, significant chemical weathering was found. Signs of chemical weathering, rather than mechanical, include rounded surfaces and pits in sand particles and the concentrations of Ca2+, Mg2+, and HCO3- in waters. Signs of mechanical weathering were also found, including sharp fracture lines in particles.
A gradient of increasing chemical weathering and decreasing mechanical weathering was found from the surface to the permafrost table. Thermal buffering reduces the frequency of frost-driven forces and thermal expansion from daily at the surface to annually at the permafrost table. The permafrost acts as a barrier to water movement, creating relatively wet condtions at depth that allow aqueous chemistry including the dissolution of dolomite to proceed.
Wednesday, August 24, 2011
Xu et al. 2009
Xu C, Guo L, Ping C-L, White DM. 2009. Chemical and isotopic characterization of size-fractionated organic matter from cryoturbated tundra soils, northern Alaska. Journal of Geophysical research 114, G03002.
These authors examined the isotopic composition and organic matter distribution in soil horizons and particle size fractions from two soils in Alaska, a moist acidic tundra and a moist non-acidic tundra. The organic matter quality and quantity in the deeper part of the active layer and down into the permafrost, material estimated to be between 3000 and 7000 years old indicated high susceptibility to microbial activity, that is, decomposition to CO2 and subsequent release to the atmosphere.
I read this paper as part of my background reading to understand the potential uses of a Picarro field-portable carbon isotope analyser; this paper includes a description of the δ13C values of organic matter throughout the soil / permafrost profiles of these Alaskan soils. These values, and the associated discussion of signatures of microbial activity, suggest it is quite possible to distinguish the source of CO2, permafrost-SOM, deep-SOM, shallow/autotrophic, based on the 13C content of effluxing CO2 and / or CO2 at various depths within a soil profile. Table 5 is particularly valuable in this regard.
These authors examined the isotopic composition and organic matter distribution in soil horizons and particle size fractions from two soils in Alaska, a moist acidic tundra and a moist non-acidic tundra. The organic matter quality and quantity in the deeper part of the active layer and down into the permafrost, material estimated to be between 3000 and 7000 years old indicated high susceptibility to microbial activity, that is, decomposition to CO2 and subsequent release to the atmosphere.
I read this paper as part of my background reading to understand the potential uses of a Picarro field-portable carbon isotope analyser; this paper includes a description of the δ13C values of organic matter throughout the soil / permafrost profiles of these Alaskan soils. These values, and the associated discussion of signatures of microbial activity, suggest it is quite possible to distinguish the source of CO2, permafrost-SOM, deep-SOM, shallow/autotrophic, based on the 13C content of effluxing CO2 and / or CO2 at various depths within a soil profile. Table 5 is particularly valuable in this regard.
Wednesday, March 31, 2010
Sørensen et al. 2006
Sørensen LI, Holmstrup M, Maraldo K, Christensen S, Christensen B. 2006. Soil fauna communities and microbial respiration in high Arctic tundra soils at Zackenberg, Northeast Greenland. Polar Biology 29: 189-195.
These authors sampled soil animals from three sites at Zackenberg station, Greenland, over three days in mid-summer. Two of the sites were considered mesic heath, with a mix of Cassiope tetragona and other High Arctic species of plants, while the third site was dominated by Dryas spp. and was considered dry heath; snow melts from the dry heath up to 20 days earlier than from the mesic heaths. Soil samples ranging down to about 6cm depth were collected, stored at 5ºC for up to two weeks, and analyzed by a range of methods in the laboratories in Europe.
Different groups of soil animals were extracted by varying methods. Soil microarthropods, a diverse group dominated by Collebola and Acari, were extracted by modified MacFadyen funnels into Benzoic acid. Enchytraeids and dipteran larvae were extracted in Baermann wet funnels with heating of the samples, into tap water. Protozoa were washed from soils in water and grown on media plates in the dark at 10ºC. Nematodes were collected by the Blender-Cotton wool method of Schouten and Arp (1991). Soil microbial respiration was measured in serum bottles, with the CO2 concentration in the headspace measured at zero, 5 and 25 hours, with a fully factorial design of nutrient amendments of C, N, and P. Soil pH and soil organic matter content, but not moisture content or other nutrient concentrations were determined using methods not clearly described, though presumably these procedures were similar to standard methods.
Once abundance and biomass data was collected, comparisons between plots were made using multivariate analysis and a software package named PRIMER 5.0. My understanding is the species counts were (log+1) transformed to reduce the influence of very abundant species, then analyzed using an approach similar to Principal Components Analysis. The result of this analysis was a clear difference between the dry heath and the two mesic heaths, while the two mesic heaths were not different from each other in parameter-space. A Bray-Curtis similarity matrix was also involved, though I’m not certain I understand how.
Different taxonomic groups were identified to different taxonomic levels; 19 species of Collembola and 7 species of Enchytraeids were found, for example, but Acari were identified to suborder (Cryptostigmata (oribatids), Prostigmata, Mesostigmata) and nematodes and protozoans were counted at those high taxonomic levels. While the two mesic heath sites were only marginally significantly different from each other, there was a clear increase in abundances in the dry heath site. For collembola at least, the dry heath site was also dominated by two highly abundant species, which differed from the majority of species in the mesic sites by being unpigmented and associated with sub-surface, rather than soil-surface, regions in the soil. The higher abundance of probably bacteria-eating nematodes at the dry heath strongly suggests higher turnover of microorganisms as well as generally higher biological activity from the higher populations of most soil animals.
These authors suggest higher organic matter decomposition rates at the dry heath, which seems reasonable given the higher animal populations there. However, their attribution of higher soil pH there to higher respiration levels seems like more of a stretch, absent supporting mineralogical and soil-nutrient data.
This paper provides an excellent example of the data that can be collected and analyzed from a brief but intensive study of soil invertebrates at a High Arctic site. In addition, meaningful information about differences in biodiversity between locations can be derived from studies of organisms not identified to fine taxonomic levels.
These authors sampled soil animals from three sites at Zackenberg station, Greenland, over three days in mid-summer. Two of the sites were considered mesic heath, with a mix of Cassiope tetragona and other High Arctic species of plants, while the third site was dominated by Dryas spp. and was considered dry heath; snow melts from the dry heath up to 20 days earlier than from the mesic heaths. Soil samples ranging down to about 6cm depth were collected, stored at 5ºC for up to two weeks, and analyzed by a range of methods in the laboratories in Europe.
Different groups of soil animals were extracted by varying methods. Soil microarthropods, a diverse group dominated by Collebola and Acari, were extracted by modified MacFadyen funnels into Benzoic acid. Enchytraeids and dipteran larvae were extracted in Baermann wet funnels with heating of the samples, into tap water. Protozoa were washed from soils in water and grown on media plates in the dark at 10ºC. Nematodes were collected by the Blender-Cotton wool method of Schouten and Arp (1991). Soil microbial respiration was measured in serum bottles, with the CO2 concentration in the headspace measured at zero, 5 and 25 hours, with a fully factorial design of nutrient amendments of C, N, and P. Soil pH and soil organic matter content, but not moisture content or other nutrient concentrations were determined using methods not clearly described, though presumably these procedures were similar to standard methods.
Once abundance and biomass data was collected, comparisons between plots were made using multivariate analysis and a software package named PRIMER 5.0. My understanding is the species counts were (log+1) transformed to reduce the influence of very abundant species, then analyzed using an approach similar to Principal Components Analysis. The result of this analysis was a clear difference between the dry heath and the two mesic heaths, while the two mesic heaths were not different from each other in parameter-space. A Bray-Curtis similarity matrix was also involved, though I’m not certain I understand how.
Different taxonomic groups were identified to different taxonomic levels; 19 species of Collembola and 7 species of Enchytraeids were found, for example, but Acari were identified to suborder (Cryptostigmata (oribatids), Prostigmata, Mesostigmata) and nematodes and protozoans were counted at those high taxonomic levels. While the two mesic heath sites were only marginally significantly different from each other, there was a clear increase in abundances in the dry heath site. For collembola at least, the dry heath site was also dominated by two highly abundant species, which differed from the majority of species in the mesic sites by being unpigmented and associated with sub-surface, rather than soil-surface, regions in the soil. The higher abundance of probably bacteria-eating nematodes at the dry heath strongly suggests higher turnover of microorganisms as well as generally higher biological activity from the higher populations of most soil animals.
These authors suggest higher organic matter decomposition rates at the dry heath, which seems reasonable given the higher animal populations there. However, their attribution of higher soil pH there to higher respiration levels seems like more of a stretch, absent supporting mineralogical and soil-nutrient data.
This paper provides an excellent example of the data that can be collected and analyzed from a brief but intensive study of soil invertebrates at a High Arctic site. In addition, meaningful information about differences in biodiversity between locations can be derived from studies of organisms not identified to fine taxonomic levels.
Thursday, March 25, 2010
Harding et al. 2001
Harding RJ, Gryning S-E, Halldin S, Lloyd CR. 2001. Progress in understanding of land surface/atmosphere exchanges at high latitudes. Theoretical and Applied Climatology 70: 5-18.
These authors review and discuss the implications of studies based in two international projects in northern Europe. WINTEX was a large study examining the effects of snow cover and long nights in winter on high-latitude ground-atmosphere exchange processes, while LAPP was an independent but complementary study examining most of the same processes in a range of high latitude sites during spring and summer.
Snow cover plays a major role in Arctic exchange processes. The high albedo of snow reflects much of the incident solar radiation, and insulates the frozen ground below, prolonging the period of snow cover to upwards of 9 months in the year in many places. Where vegetation is tall, such as in the boreal forest, the low solar angle reduces the effective net albedo of the landscape, allowing sunlight to warm the dark trees and speed springtime melting. This study mentions the importance of snow-surface aerodynamics, though it appears there is little solid information on this complex topic.
Snow melt is the major hydrological event of the year in much of the Arctic. The combination of frozen soils, very low evaporation rates, and often flat terrain means much of the Arctic is very wet or saturated while annual precipitation rates are consistent with arid or semi-arid conditions. These areas are the classic tundra systems, with abundant shallow lakes and ponds and very wet high-organic soils.
Differences in snow-surface dynamics and the timing of snowmelt create an extremely heterogeneous landscape, particularly in the vicinity of the northern treeline. There are often very large temperature and air-flow differences between patches of trees and adjacent lakes or clearings, which greatly complicate attempts to model the carbon dioxide emissions (for example) of such areas. Much of this paper is a series of evaluations of some of the models that have been applied to this region. In general, more sophisticated models that can take some of the extreme variability into account perform better than models that cannot account for differences in snow depth or insulating properties. However, this paper makes it clear that current modelling efforts still leave much to be desired in terms of predicting Arctic heat budgets and biological responses.
Water storage is also very difficult to model, and has large and variable impacts on other parts of the system. There appears to be large and unpredictable year-to-year variation in water storage and transport at the scale of catchments and basins, and the importance of soil water in controlling biological processes such as the decomposition of organic matter is large. Runoff matters, even on very gentle slopes.
This paper provides a useful overview of large-scale processes and attempts to understand these processes in the Arctic.
These authors review and discuss the implications of studies based in two international projects in northern Europe. WINTEX was a large study examining the effects of snow cover and long nights in winter on high-latitude ground-atmosphere exchange processes, while LAPP was an independent but complementary study examining most of the same processes in a range of high latitude sites during spring and summer.
Snow cover plays a major role in Arctic exchange processes. The high albedo of snow reflects much of the incident solar radiation, and insulates the frozen ground below, prolonging the period of snow cover to upwards of 9 months in the year in many places. Where vegetation is tall, such as in the boreal forest, the low solar angle reduces the effective net albedo of the landscape, allowing sunlight to warm the dark trees and speed springtime melting. This study mentions the importance of snow-surface aerodynamics, though it appears there is little solid information on this complex topic.
Snow melt is the major hydrological event of the year in much of the Arctic. The combination of frozen soils, very low evaporation rates, and often flat terrain means much of the Arctic is very wet or saturated while annual precipitation rates are consistent with arid or semi-arid conditions. These areas are the classic tundra systems, with abundant shallow lakes and ponds and very wet high-organic soils.
Differences in snow-surface dynamics and the timing of snowmelt create an extremely heterogeneous landscape, particularly in the vicinity of the northern treeline. There are often very large temperature and air-flow differences between patches of trees and adjacent lakes or clearings, which greatly complicate attempts to model the carbon dioxide emissions (for example) of such areas. Much of this paper is a series of evaluations of some of the models that have been applied to this region. In general, more sophisticated models that can take some of the extreme variability into account perform better than models that cannot account for differences in snow depth or insulating properties. However, this paper makes it clear that current modelling efforts still leave much to be desired in terms of predicting Arctic heat budgets and biological responses.
Water storage is also very difficult to model, and has large and variable impacts on other parts of the system. There appears to be large and unpredictable year-to-year variation in water storage and transport at the scale of catchments and basins, and the importance of soil water in controlling biological processes such as the decomposition of organic matter is large. Runoff matters, even on very gentle slopes.
This paper provides a useful overview of large-scale processes and attempts to understand these processes in the Arctic.
Friday, February 19, 2010
Liptzin 2006
Liptzin D. 2006. A banded vegetation pattern in a High Arctic community on Axel Heiberg Island, Nunavut, Canada. Arctic, Antarctic, and Alpine Research 38: 216-223.
This author attempted to explain the observation of banded vegetation on a slope that lacked the usual factors that generate such patterns. In temperate and tropical locations, banded vegetation, also known as “tiger stripes”, forms on shallow slopes in dry areas with a consistent direction of water flow. Plants at a position on the slope increase water retention and facilitate further colonization by plants. Similarly, some locations experience consistent wind direction carrying sea spray that kills trees at some positions. In cold environments, patterned ground from cryoturbation on shallow slopes can also lead to banded vegetation. However, the study site in this paper lacks all of these features, including cryoturbation despite the presence of permafrost within 50cm at most locations.
Some aspect of soil properties is the obvious explanatory hypothesis, which this author explores after describing the transects measuring plant diversity and the soil pits used to examine soil properties. In general, features that would normally be expected to influence plant diversity and abundance such as soil moisture or exchangeable cation levels, had no significant impact in the various statistical tests employed in this study. However, soil type did have some effect, as a few species of plants were found only on sandy soil, and nitrogen levels were negatively correlated with species richness.
The discussion section of this paper is an excellent example of a chain of logical reasoning working through a series of potential explanations. While this paper is interesting, it’s only relevant to my own studies in a narrow area around potential starting points in looking for explanations for whatever patterns I may find in my biogeography studies in 2010. However, this paper seems remarkably suitable as an introduction to the basics of modern soil science research, and may be relevant to my not-quite-mothballed interest in an undergraduate course about the current state of the scientific literature.
This author attempted to explain the observation of banded vegetation on a slope that lacked the usual factors that generate such patterns. In temperate and tropical locations, banded vegetation, also known as “tiger stripes”, forms on shallow slopes in dry areas with a consistent direction of water flow. Plants at a position on the slope increase water retention and facilitate further colonization by plants. Similarly, some locations experience consistent wind direction carrying sea spray that kills trees at some positions. In cold environments, patterned ground from cryoturbation on shallow slopes can also lead to banded vegetation. However, the study site in this paper lacks all of these features, including cryoturbation despite the presence of permafrost within 50cm at most locations.
Some aspect of soil properties is the obvious explanatory hypothesis, which this author explores after describing the transects measuring plant diversity and the soil pits used to examine soil properties. In general, features that would normally be expected to influence plant diversity and abundance such as soil moisture or exchangeable cation levels, had no significant impact in the various statistical tests employed in this study. However, soil type did have some effect, as a few species of plants were found only on sandy soil, and nitrogen levels were negatively correlated with species richness.
The discussion section of this paper is an excellent example of a chain of logical reasoning working through a series of potential explanations. While this paper is interesting, it’s only relevant to my own studies in a narrow area around potential starting points in looking for explanations for whatever patterns I may find in my biogeography studies in 2010. However, this paper seems remarkably suitable as an introduction to the basics of modern soil science research, and may be relevant to my not-quite-mothballed interest in an undergraduate course about the current state of the scientific literature.
Saturday, January 9, 2010
Wagner et al. 2009
Wagner D, Kobabe S, Liebner S. 2009. Bacterial community structure and carbon turnover in permafrost-affected soils of the Lena Delta, northeastern Siberia. Canadian Journal of Microbiology 55: 73-83.
These authors examined the microbial communities at two depth bands (near-surface and near-permafrost) in low-centred tundra polygons at the vast permafrost wetland of the delta of the Lena River. The delta covers more than 60 000 km^2, and much of it appears to be a reserve or national park of Russia. The CAVM (Walker et al. 2002) describes most of the delta as vegetation type W2, sedge, moss, dwarf-shrub wetland, and satellite images from Google maps shows very extensive lake and pond coverage of the landscape. In short, it’s pretty wet, and generally cold.
The general finding of this paper is that while near-surface communities include a wide diversity of aerobic and facultatively-anaerobic bacteria, the deeper, colder, anaerobic portions of the soil contain almost no aerobes, and are instead dominated by “fermenting” species capable of decomposing recalcitrant organic carbon molecules under negative-redox conditions. There is a sharp temperature gradient, which combined with the poorer quality of carbon, the lack of oxygen and negative redox conditions, and the general water saturation at depth creates conditions near the permafrost suitable only for the slow microbial metabolisms. None of this is particularly surprising, but the observation of decreased biodiversity with water saturation does suggest the worrying possibility that increased water in this system, driven by melting permafrost and climate change (particularly upstream in the long and North-flowing Lena) could drive these microbial communities to lose some “physiological skills” such as the ability to oxidize methane, a metabolic pathway possessed only by some aerobic prokaryotes.
This paper is quite important to my own work, I think. Besides emphasizing the role of water content in structuring soil chemical and especially biological conditions, the description of the methods used to measure microbial biodiversity should be useful. However, while the BIOLOG plates seem interesting, the results of this technique are not at all well explained in this paper. I do not know what is indicated by the relationship shown in Figure 3, for example, of changes in colour development associated with carbon turnover of various categories of organic substrates. Several of the figures are simple plots of principal component analysis (PCA), literally just PC1 vs. PC2 with some outlines drawn around some clusters. I’m sure there is more of interest in this paper besides the coarse outline of biodiversity differences in communities, but without a more thorough explanation of the nearly-raw data I cannot see it.
These authors examined the microbial communities at two depth bands (near-surface and near-permafrost) in low-centred tundra polygons at the vast permafrost wetland of the delta of the Lena River. The delta covers more than 60 000 km^2, and much of it appears to be a reserve or national park of Russia. The CAVM (Walker et al. 2002) describes most of the delta as vegetation type W2, sedge, moss, dwarf-shrub wetland, and satellite images from Google maps shows very extensive lake and pond coverage of the landscape. In short, it’s pretty wet, and generally cold.
The general finding of this paper is that while near-surface communities include a wide diversity of aerobic and facultatively-anaerobic bacteria, the deeper, colder, anaerobic portions of the soil contain almost no aerobes, and are instead dominated by “fermenting” species capable of decomposing recalcitrant organic carbon molecules under negative-redox conditions. There is a sharp temperature gradient, which combined with the poorer quality of carbon, the lack of oxygen and negative redox conditions, and the general water saturation at depth creates conditions near the permafrost suitable only for the slow microbial metabolisms. None of this is particularly surprising, but the observation of decreased biodiversity with water saturation does suggest the worrying possibility that increased water in this system, driven by melting permafrost and climate change (particularly upstream in the long and North-flowing Lena) could drive these microbial communities to lose some “physiological skills” such as the ability to oxidize methane, a metabolic pathway possessed only by some aerobic prokaryotes.
This paper is quite important to my own work, I think. Besides emphasizing the role of water content in structuring soil chemical and especially biological conditions, the description of the methods used to measure microbial biodiversity should be useful. However, while the BIOLOG plates seem interesting, the results of this technique are not at all well explained in this paper. I do not know what is indicated by the relationship shown in Figure 3, for example, of changes in colour development associated with carbon turnover of various categories of organic substrates. Several of the figures are simple plots of principal component analysis (PCA), literally just PC1 vs. PC2 with some outlines drawn around some clusters. I’m sure there is more of interest in this paper besides the coarse outline of biodiversity differences in communities, but without a more thorough explanation of the nearly-raw data I cannot see it.
Tuesday, January 5, 2010
Elberling 2007
Elberling B. 2007. Annual soil CO2 effluxes in the High Arctic: the role of snow thickness and vegetation type. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 39: 646-654.
This author studied the total annual efflux of CO2 at three vegetation communities in Endalen valley on Svalbard. The three communities are each dominated by one characteristic species of plant, and are named accordingly: Dryas, Cassiope, and Salix, and from the description of the sites and their environmental parameters, there appears to be high agreement between these communities and those found at Alexandra Fjord, Ellesmere Island.
The depth and duration of snow cover was a major factor controlling (directly and indirectly) soil conditions and thus respiration. Snow depth varied with vegetation type, though the causal relationship is probably snow to plants, via soil temperature (more snow = higher winter temperatures) and soil moisture content (snow accumulates at and melts into depressions and certain slope positions). Higher temperatures and wetter conditions correlated with higher soil respiration, both in winter and summer. All sites experienced a brief period of water saturation in the upper 5cm of the soil during spring thaw, though sites varied in when thaw happened, with Dryas first and Salix last, corresponding with winter snow cover depth.
Soil conditions among the sites seem to have been broadly similar; not surprising considering the close proximity of sites and the consistent soil type across the valley, though soil under Cassiope tetragonal patches was more acidic. This acidity seems related to a reduced concentration of base cations (especially Ca2+ and K+) under Cassiope plants.
Summer water content did not correlate with annual CO2 flux, which this author attributes to the generally well-drained soils, a lack of large precipitation events, and long periods without rain leading to typically dry soils everywhere, though soil respiration at the Dryas site may have been water-limited, as this was the driest site.
Winter temperatures in the soil averaged warmer than -10ºC at all sites, warm enough for microbial activity. A burst of CO2 during spring thaw was not predicted from soil parameters, but was attributed to increasing microbial activity associated with warming temperatures and the release of high-quality organic material from winter-killed microbial cells. Winter CO2 efflux averages were 0.11 to 0.28 µmol / m^2 / s, not far from values we found (for example) at the Cassiope site at Alexandra Fjord.
This paper contains much that is valuable to my current research, including both the data and patterns found and the discussion with other relevant references.
This author studied the total annual efflux of CO2 at three vegetation communities in Endalen valley on Svalbard. The three communities are each dominated by one characteristic species of plant, and are named accordingly: Dryas, Cassiope, and Salix, and from the description of the sites and their environmental parameters, there appears to be high agreement between these communities and those found at Alexandra Fjord, Ellesmere Island.
The depth and duration of snow cover was a major factor controlling (directly and indirectly) soil conditions and thus respiration. Snow depth varied with vegetation type, though the causal relationship is probably snow to plants, via soil temperature (more snow = higher winter temperatures) and soil moisture content (snow accumulates at and melts into depressions and certain slope positions). Higher temperatures and wetter conditions correlated with higher soil respiration, both in winter and summer. All sites experienced a brief period of water saturation in the upper 5cm of the soil during spring thaw, though sites varied in when thaw happened, with Dryas first and Salix last, corresponding with winter snow cover depth.
Soil conditions among the sites seem to have been broadly similar; not surprising considering the close proximity of sites and the consistent soil type across the valley, though soil under Cassiope tetragonal patches was more acidic. This acidity seems related to a reduced concentration of base cations (especially Ca2+ and K+) under Cassiope plants.
Summer water content did not correlate with annual CO2 flux, which this author attributes to the generally well-drained soils, a lack of large precipitation events, and long periods without rain leading to typically dry soils everywhere, though soil respiration at the Dryas site may have been water-limited, as this was the driest site.
Winter temperatures in the soil averaged warmer than -10ºC at all sites, warm enough for microbial activity. A burst of CO2 during spring thaw was not predicted from soil parameters, but was attributed to increasing microbial activity associated with warming temperatures and the release of high-quality organic material from winter-killed microbial cells. Winter CO2 efflux averages were 0.11 to 0.28 µmol / m^2 / s, not far from values we found (for example) at the Cassiope site at Alexandra Fjord.
This paper contains much that is valuable to my current research, including both the data and patterns found and the discussion with other relevant references.
Friday, November 6, 2009
Elberling et al. 2004
Elberling B, Jakobsen BH, Berg P, Sondergaard J, Sigsgaard C. 2004. Influence of vegetation, temperature, and water content on soil carbon distribution and mineralization in four High Arctic soils. Arctic, Antarctic, and Alpine Research, 36: 528-538.
These authors examined the carbon pools and carbon dioxide effluxes from four ecosystems at Zackenberg, in north-east Greenland. Their four ecosystems are very similar to the Alexandra Fjord systems of Dryas (CAVM P1), Cassiope (P2), Salix (G3), and Wet Sedge Meadow (W1).
There are two major sources of soil CO2: respiration by plant roots, and microbial respiration. Which of these two processes dominates CO2 production is a matter of some debate, with studies in the 1990s and 2000s indicating either when measuring similar arctic ecosystems. This study does not settle that debate, with estimated ratios of the two processes ranging from 9:1 to 1:9. What is clear is that plants and microbes compete for resources in arctic soils, with considerable variation in both time and space, even among vegetation communities in one valley with a consistent above-ground climate.
These soils include a buried A-horizon, with birch leaves present in pockets of organic-rich former topsoil indicative of surface conditions during the previous climatic mild period approximately 5000 years ago. These pockets of “Ab” create something of a wildcard situation for CO2 evolution, being responsible for a considerable fraction of the measured CO2 efflux at all ecosystems to varying extent.
To measure subsurface concentrations of CO2, these authors extended a probe to a range of depths and connected it to their gas analyzer also used for measuring surface fluxes, much as we have done at Alexandra Fjord. However, their gas analyzer only measures CO2, and they did not allow their probes to equilibrate to subsurface conditions for very long; a few minutes seems to be the usual protocol in this case.
A range of soil parameters were measured, and in general variation between vegetation types in these parameters exceeded variation within. The Cassiope system was the most variable, but also had the most variable Ab layers, which probably accounted for most of the variation. These patterns of variation at all ecosystems, however, suggest that the effects of climate change will not be uniform across the High Arctic, with increased temperatures leading to perhaps increases or decreases in the decomposition of buried organic matter and CO2 effluxes.
Like our own results from Alexandra Fjord, the Salix ecosystem at Zackenberg showed the highest below-ground CO2 concentrations. At Zackenberg, CO2 concentrations in Salix were mostly related to microbial decomposition of organic matter, with reduced soil water content leading to more oxygenation and higher temperatures, both increasing the rate of decomposition. In contrast, the water-saturated Eriophorum system had very high carbon stores and the highest CO2 efflux, but a decrease in water levels here leads to a shift from methane production to CO2 production, rather than a simple increase in one rate.
Overall, this paper provides some results and considerations of high relevance to my own work, especially given the high overlap in the range of ecosystems under consideration and the range of methods employed in their analysis. Their systems are not identical to those I studied; for example, the Dryas system at Zackenberg appears to be considerably drier and with less vegetation cover compared to the system with the same name at Alexandra Fjord.
These authors examined the carbon pools and carbon dioxide effluxes from four ecosystems at Zackenberg, in north-east Greenland. Their four ecosystems are very similar to the Alexandra Fjord systems of Dryas (CAVM P1), Cassiope (P2), Salix (G3), and Wet Sedge Meadow (W1).
There are two major sources of soil CO2: respiration by plant roots, and microbial respiration. Which of these two processes dominates CO2 production is a matter of some debate, with studies in the 1990s and 2000s indicating either when measuring similar arctic ecosystems. This study does not settle that debate, with estimated ratios of the two processes ranging from 9:1 to 1:9. What is clear is that plants and microbes compete for resources in arctic soils, with considerable variation in both time and space, even among vegetation communities in one valley with a consistent above-ground climate.
These soils include a buried A-horizon, with birch leaves present in pockets of organic-rich former topsoil indicative of surface conditions during the previous climatic mild period approximately 5000 years ago. These pockets of “Ab” create something of a wildcard situation for CO2 evolution, being responsible for a considerable fraction of the measured CO2 efflux at all ecosystems to varying extent.
To measure subsurface concentrations of CO2, these authors extended a probe to a range of depths and connected it to their gas analyzer also used for measuring surface fluxes, much as we have done at Alexandra Fjord. However, their gas analyzer only measures CO2, and they did not allow their probes to equilibrate to subsurface conditions for very long; a few minutes seems to be the usual protocol in this case.
A range of soil parameters were measured, and in general variation between vegetation types in these parameters exceeded variation within. The Cassiope system was the most variable, but also had the most variable Ab layers, which probably accounted for most of the variation. These patterns of variation at all ecosystems, however, suggest that the effects of climate change will not be uniform across the High Arctic, with increased temperatures leading to perhaps increases or decreases in the decomposition of buried organic matter and CO2 effluxes.
Like our own results from Alexandra Fjord, the Salix ecosystem at Zackenberg showed the highest below-ground CO2 concentrations. At Zackenberg, CO2 concentrations in Salix were mostly related to microbial decomposition of organic matter, with reduced soil water content leading to more oxygenation and higher temperatures, both increasing the rate of decomposition. In contrast, the water-saturated Eriophorum system had very high carbon stores and the highest CO2 efflux, but a decrease in water levels here leads to a shift from methane production to CO2 production, rather than a simple increase in one rate.
Overall, this paper provides some results and considerations of high relevance to my own work, especially given the high overlap in the range of ecosystems under consideration and the range of methods employed in their analysis. Their systems are not identical to those I studied; for example, the Dryas system at Zackenberg appears to be considerably drier and with less vegetation cover compared to the system with the same name at Alexandra Fjord.
Monday, November 2, 2009
Jones and Henry 2003
Jones GA, Henry GHR. 2003. Primary plant succession on recently deglaciated terrain in the Canadian High Arctic. Journal of Biogeography 30: 277-296.
These authors examined five glacial foregrounds on Ellesmere Island, one intensively and the other 4 “extensively”, to determine patterns of succession among plant communities on sterile ground. The ecological literature recognizes several different modes of succession, including a categorization by Henry and Svoboda (1987) based on the relative strengths of biotic and abiotic factors. This model of succession recognizes 3 modes; directional succession with species replacement, directional succession without species replacement, and non-directional succession without replacement. They are arranged in increasing importance of abiotic factors, referred to here as “environmental resistance”, which operates in opposition to “biological driving forces”.
In temperate regions, where much of the relevant ecological theory has been developed, biotic factors are mainly competition. In the High Arctic, a successional pattern consistent with directional-with-replacement was found, demonstrating that this can occur even in environments with obviously severe abiotic factors. However, these authors argue that the biotic factor driving this succession was probably not competition, because total plant cover remains below 10% by area even at the fourth stage recognized here, and species richness is always very low. The polar oasis landscape with 80-100% plant cover was never reached within the approximately 50-year old glacial forelands examined by these authors, though it is likely that competition is important in that “stage 5” level of High Arctic succession.
Other biotic variables suggested playing a role in successional dynamics in the High Arctic included facilitation and life-history characteristics. These factors are not independent; later successional species such as Salix arctica appear not to be able to establish until soil fertility has been improved by mats of very-early-colonizing mosses, and are long-lived, slow-growing species that contribute little to the early seed bank and seed rain. Thus, multiple plant and environmental characteristics appear to interact when structuring early communities.
I read this paper to try to gain some understanding of ecological succession and the role of time-since-deglaciation among the ecosystems of Alexandra Fjord. Rather than being distinct successional stages in sequence as I had previously supposed, it appears the various lowland ecosystems are all of a similar age, and have different vegetation communities as a result of other factors besides simply relative proximity to the Twin Glacier. Dryas integrefolia and Cassiope tetragona were important parts of this study, and both appear in stage 4, after primary-colonizing mosses, and early-colonizing forbs such as Papaver radicatum and early-colonizing deciduous shrubs like Saxifraga spp. Both Dryas and Cassiope form associations with mycorrhyzal fungi, a requirement that may slow their colonization of novel habitats; earlier-spreading plants do not form these associations, and instead may be limited by seed dispersal.
This was helpful in organizing the structure of the manuscript I am currently working on, which will describe some of the soil biotic communities both in the Alexandra Fjord lowlands and in the adjacent polar desert. It is not a simple story of succession from one ecosystem to the next, but succession does play a role.
These authors examined five glacial foregrounds on Ellesmere Island, one intensively and the other 4 “extensively”, to determine patterns of succession among plant communities on sterile ground. The ecological literature recognizes several different modes of succession, including a categorization by Henry and Svoboda (1987) based on the relative strengths of biotic and abiotic factors. This model of succession recognizes 3 modes; directional succession with species replacement, directional succession without species replacement, and non-directional succession without replacement. They are arranged in increasing importance of abiotic factors, referred to here as “environmental resistance”, which operates in opposition to “biological driving forces”.
In temperate regions, where much of the relevant ecological theory has been developed, biotic factors are mainly competition. In the High Arctic, a successional pattern consistent with directional-with-replacement was found, demonstrating that this can occur even in environments with obviously severe abiotic factors. However, these authors argue that the biotic factor driving this succession was probably not competition, because total plant cover remains below 10% by area even at the fourth stage recognized here, and species richness is always very low. The polar oasis landscape with 80-100% plant cover was never reached within the approximately 50-year old glacial forelands examined by these authors, though it is likely that competition is important in that “stage 5” level of High Arctic succession.
Other biotic variables suggested playing a role in successional dynamics in the High Arctic included facilitation and life-history characteristics. These factors are not independent; later successional species such as Salix arctica appear not to be able to establish until soil fertility has been improved by mats of very-early-colonizing mosses, and are long-lived, slow-growing species that contribute little to the early seed bank and seed rain. Thus, multiple plant and environmental characteristics appear to interact when structuring early communities.
I read this paper to try to gain some understanding of ecological succession and the role of time-since-deglaciation among the ecosystems of Alexandra Fjord. Rather than being distinct successional stages in sequence as I had previously supposed, it appears the various lowland ecosystems are all of a similar age, and have different vegetation communities as a result of other factors besides simply relative proximity to the Twin Glacier. Dryas integrefolia and Cassiope tetragona were important parts of this study, and both appear in stage 4, after primary-colonizing mosses, and early-colonizing forbs such as Papaver radicatum and early-colonizing deciduous shrubs like Saxifraga spp. Both Dryas and Cassiope form associations with mycorrhyzal fungi, a requirement that may slow their colonization of novel habitats; earlier-spreading plants do not form these associations, and instead may be limited by seed dispersal.
This was helpful in organizing the structure of the manuscript I am currently working on, which will describe some of the soil biotic communities both in the Alexandra Fjord lowlands and in the adjacent polar desert. It is not a simple story of succession from one ecosystem to the next, but succession does play a role.
Tuesday, October 6, 2009
Cockell and Stokes 2004
Cockell CS, Stokes MD. 2004. Widespread colonization by polar hypoliths. Nature 431: 414.
These authors present a short report about the colonization of the undersides of rocks in the polar deserts by cyanobacteria and unicellular green algae. Where rocks have a protected but accessible underside, these organisms colonize, forming a pale green band a few centimetres across, between the part of the rock too exposed and dry, and too dark for photosynthesis. In polygon terrain, where the ground is sorted by frost heave (“periglacial processes”) and even large rocks are periodically jostled, areas of finer texture form in the centers of polygons, with larger rocks around the edges. The edge rocks were 100% colonized, while central areas were 5% colonized.
These authors present a short report about the colonization of the undersides of rocks in the polar deserts by cyanobacteria and unicellular green algae. Where rocks have a protected but accessible underside, these organisms colonize, forming a pale green band a few centimetres across, between the part of the rock too exposed and dry, and too dark for photosynthesis. In polygon terrain, where the ground is sorted by frost heave (“periglacial processes”) and even large rocks are periodically jostled, areas of finer texture form in the centers of polygons, with larger rocks around the edges. The edge rocks were 100% colonized, while central areas were 5% colonized.
Wednesday, September 23, 2009
Uchida et al. 2002
Uchida M, Muraoka H, Nakatsubo T, Bekku Y, Ueno T, Kanda H, Koizumi H. 2002. Net photosynthesis, respiration, and production of the moss Sanionia uncinata on a glacier foreland in the High Arctic, Ny-Ålesund, Svalbard. Arctic, Antarctic, and Alpine Research 34: 287-292.
These authors constructed a model of moss physiology that uses meteorological data to estimate productivity, based on data collected during one field season at Svalbard. In 2000, these authors measured the response of a common High Arctic moss species to water content, temperature, and light, then determined the relationship between those variables and available meteorological data, then applied previous-years meteorological data to their model and estimated previous-years productivity. These estimates suggest a great deal of variation in year-to-year productivity, driven largely by differences in water availability. Water content of fresh moss tissue was the single most important controlling variable in moss photosynthesis rates. The response to temperature was nearly flat between 7 and 23ºC, with near-freezing photosynthetic rates still a large fraction of maximum under saturating light conditions. Saturating light conditions were estimated at near 800µmol/m^2/s, which is not uncommon on sunny days in this environment.
The glacial foreground in question is at 79º North, but is not polar desert as it receives approximately 360mm of precipitation per year. The moss species studied is dominant in the local ecosystem, but appears to represent an intermediate successional stage, with high-productivity vascular plants replacing bryophytes in older sites in the area (i.e. further from the toe of the glacier).
These authors constructed a model of moss physiology that uses meteorological data to estimate productivity, based on data collected during one field season at Svalbard. In 2000, these authors measured the response of a common High Arctic moss species to water content, temperature, and light, then determined the relationship between those variables and available meteorological data, then applied previous-years meteorological data to their model and estimated previous-years productivity. These estimates suggest a great deal of variation in year-to-year productivity, driven largely by differences in water availability. Water content of fresh moss tissue was the single most important controlling variable in moss photosynthesis rates. The response to temperature was nearly flat between 7 and 23ºC, with near-freezing photosynthetic rates still a large fraction of maximum under saturating light conditions. Saturating light conditions were estimated at near 800µmol/m^2/s, which is not uncommon on sunny days in this environment.
The glacial foreground in question is at 79º North, but is not polar desert as it receives approximately 360mm of precipitation per year. The moss species studied is dominant in the local ecosystem, but appears to represent an intermediate successional stage, with high-productivity vascular plants replacing bryophytes in older sites in the area (i.e. further from the toe of the glacier).
Friday, September 18, 2009
Barrett et al. 2006
Barrett JE, Virginia RA, Wall DH, Cary SC, Adams BJ, Hacker AL, Aislabie JM. 2006. Co-variation in soil biodiversity and biogeochemistry in northern and southern Victoria Land, Antarctica. Antarctic Science 18: 535-548.
These authors examined soil biota at three sites across about 7 degrees of latitude in the drier part of Antarctica. The latitudinal gradient here covers a range of different ecosystems, from relatively wet, more northern and coastal systems to extremely arid and barren southern systems. Here, latitude is not studied for its effects on ecosystems; its effects on ecosystems are exploited to cover the widest available range of conditions. Within each of the three sites, one wet and one dry location were chosen a priori based on obvious surface features such as meltwater drainage channels and the presence of moss beds. At each location, a set of transects were laid out and samples were collected. To quote them directly:
Soil invertebrates were investigated using both morphological and molecular techniques. There are only four metazoan phyla with any significant presence in Antarctica’s soils (Arthropoda, Nematoda, Rotifera, and Tardigrada), all of which are difficult to identify to species using standard morphological methods. While these authors were able to identify nematodes to species, rotifers, tardigrades, and mites were handled as MOTUs, molecular operational taxonomic units (Floyd et al. 2002). These MOTUs, based on ribosomal DNA sequences, were also used to generate a series of cladograms used to assess biodiversity at the research sites. Unfortunately, while the text descriptions of the methods and results are reasonably clear, the figures relating to the biodiversity and metazoan-molecular work are confusing and poorly described.
The results of the microbial analyses are broadly similar to the metazoan dataset. These authors were able to examine biodiversity at the level of microbes, and compare this diversity to both soil chemical characteristics such as water content and C:N ratio, and to the metazoan diversity. Perhaps surprisingly, they found no evidence to support the hypothesis of top-down control on bacterial populations by metazoan predators, as there was no correlation between DGGE and FAME-derived estimates of bacterial population size and species richness and cladogram and sugar-extract-derived estimates of nematode biodiversity. Bacterial diversity is described as not varying across sites, though community composition does. I take this to mean that while total species richness of bacteria (as measured by DGGE) was constant across sites, species turnover (Beta-diversity) was high. This is interesting to me, though not mentioned in the paper, because it seems to directly contradict the microbial-biogeography hypothesis of “everything is everywhere”. There is a mention in the description of this comparison of the importance of geography in structuring biodiversity, which reads to me like an opportunity to apply explicit geospatial techniques to their dataset.
Overall, while it is true that Antarctic soil ecosystems are extremely simple relative to other systems, there are a great many complex and variable interactions between even the few components of these systems, creating a great deal of complexity. This paper will be very useful to me in structuring some of my own investigations in the Arctic.
These authors examined soil biota at three sites across about 7 degrees of latitude in the drier part of Antarctica. The latitudinal gradient here covers a range of different ecosystems, from relatively wet, more northern and coastal systems to extremely arid and barren southern systems. Here, latitude is not studied for its effects on ecosystems; its effects on ecosystems are exploited to cover the widest available range of conditions. Within each of the three sites, one wet and one dry location were chosen a priori based on obvious surface features such as meltwater drainage channels and the presence of moss beds. At each location, a set of transects were laid out and samples were collected. To quote them directly:
"We investigated the structure (bacterial and metazoan diversity) and functioning (soil respiration) of soil communities and the influence of soil biogeochemical properties (organic matter, inorganic nutrients, physicochemical properties) on habitat suitability."This is quite similar in many respects to my planned investigations in the Arctic polar desert. The list of molecular techniques used in this paper, for example, serves as a useful guide or checklist of the procedures I intend to use.
Soil invertebrates were investigated using both morphological and molecular techniques. There are only four metazoan phyla with any significant presence in Antarctica’s soils (Arthropoda, Nematoda, Rotifera, and Tardigrada), all of which are difficult to identify to species using standard morphological methods. While these authors were able to identify nematodes to species, rotifers, tardigrades, and mites were handled as MOTUs, molecular operational taxonomic units (Floyd et al. 2002). These MOTUs, based on ribosomal DNA sequences, were also used to generate a series of cladograms used to assess biodiversity at the research sites. Unfortunately, while the text descriptions of the methods and results are reasonably clear, the figures relating to the biodiversity and metazoan-molecular work are confusing and poorly described.
The results of the microbial analyses are broadly similar to the metazoan dataset. These authors were able to examine biodiversity at the level of microbes, and compare this diversity to both soil chemical characteristics such as water content and C:N ratio, and to the metazoan diversity. Perhaps surprisingly, they found no evidence to support the hypothesis of top-down control on bacterial populations by metazoan predators, as there was no correlation between DGGE and FAME-derived estimates of bacterial population size and species richness and cladogram and sugar-extract-derived estimates of nematode biodiversity. Bacterial diversity is described as not varying across sites, though community composition does. I take this to mean that while total species richness of bacteria (as measured by DGGE) was constant across sites, species turnover (Beta-diversity) was high. This is interesting to me, though not mentioned in the paper, because it seems to directly contradict the microbial-biogeography hypothesis of “everything is everywhere”. There is a mention in the description of this comparison of the importance of geography in structuring biodiversity, which reads to me like an opportunity to apply explicit geospatial techniques to their dataset.
Overall, while it is true that Antarctic soil ecosystems are extremely simple relative to other systems, there are a great many complex and variable interactions between even the few components of these systems, creating a great deal of complexity. This paper will be very useful to me in structuring some of my own investigations in the Arctic.
Friday, September 4, 2009
Broll et al. 1999
Broll G, Tarnocai C, Mueller G. 1999. Interactions between vegetation, nutrients and moisture in soils in the Pangnirtung Pass area, Baffin island, Canada. Permafrost and Periglacial Processes 10: 265-277.
These authors examined soils from 6 pedons in Pangnirtung Pass, a north-south pass between mountains on Cumberland Peninsula. Three pedons were from moist soils, and three from dry soils. The moisture content drove a major difference in soil structure: dry soils are not cryoturbated, resulting in strong differences in nutrient content and mineralization rates.
The goal of the study was to compare in detail these differences between dry and moist soils. This seems very similar to my PhD goals surrounding examinations of Polar Desert soils. This study thus represents a possible template for some of my own investigations.
These authors examined soils from 6 pedons in Pangnirtung Pass, a north-south pass between mountains on Cumberland Peninsula. Three pedons were from moist soils, and three from dry soils. The moisture content drove a major difference in soil structure: dry soils are not cryoturbated, resulting in strong differences in nutrient content and mineralization rates.
The goal of the study was to compare in detail these differences between dry and moist soils. This seems very similar to my PhD goals surrounding examinations of Polar Desert soils. This study thus represents a possible template for some of my own investigations.
Wednesday, September 2, 2009
Bockheim 1979
Bockheim JG. 1979. Properties and relative age of soils of southwestern Cumberland peninsula, Baffin island, N.W.T., Canada. Arctic and Alpine Research 11: 289-306.
This author sampled soils from more than 60 sites on the Cumberland peninsula of Baffin Island, mostly near the hamlet of Pangnirtung. This covered soils from two tundra vegetations (Dwarf shrub-sedge-moss-lichen on lowlands and coastal, stony sedge-moss-lichen in highlands and northern fjords) and the Polar Desert of Baffin island. The tundra soils ranged from mesic to subxeric, while the desert near Penny icecap was xeric. A similar gradient driven by latitude rather than altitude is referenced in Tedrow (1973).
Descriptions are made of the pH and various exchangeable and free minerals in the soils, along with how those components change with depth in each area. pH increases with depth, for example, especially in the Polar Desert. Phosphorus was found in surprisingly high levels in all soils. The active layer, or at least the layer above the permafrost, is much deeper than found on Ellesmere island, and appears to be deeper than 1m everywhere studied in this paper.
This author sampled soils from more than 60 sites on the Cumberland peninsula of Baffin Island, mostly near the hamlet of Pangnirtung. This covered soils from two tundra vegetations (Dwarf shrub-sedge-moss-lichen on lowlands and coastal, stony sedge-moss-lichen in highlands and northern fjords) and the Polar Desert of Baffin island. The tundra soils ranged from mesic to subxeric, while the desert near Penny icecap was xeric. A similar gradient driven by latitude rather than altitude is referenced in Tedrow (1973).
Descriptions are made of the pH and various exchangeable and free minerals in the soils, along with how those components change with depth in each area. pH increases with depth, for example, especially in the Polar Desert. Phosphorus was found in surprisingly high levels in all soils. The active layer, or at least the layer above the permafrost, is much deeper than found on Ellesmere island, and appears to be deeper than 1m everywhere studied in this paper.
Niederberger et al. 2008
Neiderberger TD, McDonald IR, Hacker AL, Soo RM, Barrett JE, Wall DH, Cary SC. 2008. Microbial community composition in soils of Northern Victoria Land, Antarctica. Environmental Microbiology 10: 1713-1724.
These authors present an analysis of a large collection of data regarding both microbial and metazoan biodiversity at relatively small scales in one part of Taylor Valley, Antarctica, one of the famous Dry Valleys. This contributes to both the Latitudinal Gradient Project, an international effort to characterize Antarctica, and to the biogeographical debate regarding the distribution and community assemblages of microbes and soil microfauna.
Biodiversity was higher than expected based on the physical characteristics of this extreme environment, and was much more variable at small (~200m) spatial scales. While the microbes identified by 16s sequences were not particularly surprising, the changes in community composition between study sites was high. This supports the hypothesis that extreme environments “select for” particular microbial physiologies, and that differences in soil physical features such as moisture and temperature are highly important, in distinct contrast to the “everything is everywhere” hypothesis of microbial biogeography.
NB October 1 2009: the “everything is everwhere” hypothesis (Beijerinck 1913) includes the second clause “the environment selects”, which implies my earlier impressions, above, are incorrect. This paper’s demonstration that extreme environments select for particular soil communities, and that local-scale variables such as moisture and temperature, rather than regional-scale variables such as climate factors, actually supports Beijerinck’s (1913) hypothesis, rather than countering it.
These authors present an analysis of a large collection of data regarding both microbial and metazoan biodiversity at relatively small scales in one part of Taylor Valley, Antarctica, one of the famous Dry Valleys. This contributes to both the Latitudinal Gradient Project, an international effort to characterize Antarctica, and to the biogeographical debate regarding the distribution and community assemblages of microbes and soil microfauna.
Biodiversity was higher than expected based on the physical characteristics of this extreme environment, and was much more variable at small (~200m) spatial scales. While the microbes identified by 16s sequences were not particularly surprising, the changes in community composition between study sites was high. This supports the hypothesis that extreme environments “select for” particular microbial physiologies, and that differences in soil physical features such as moisture and temperature are highly important, in distinct contrast to the “everything is everywhere” hypothesis of microbial biogeography.
NB October 1 2009: the “everything is everwhere” hypothesis (Beijerinck 1913) includes the second clause “the environment selects”, which implies my earlier impressions, above, are incorrect. This paper’s demonstration that extreme environments select for particular soil communities, and that local-scale variables such as moisture and temperature, rather than regional-scale variables such as climate factors, actually supports Beijerinck’s (1913) hypothesis, rather than countering it.
Tuesday, March 17, 2009
Marion et al. 1997
Marion GM, Henry GHR, Freckman DW, Johnstone J, Jones G, Jones MH, Levesque E, Molau U, Molgaard P, Parsons AN, Svoboda J, Virginia RA. 1997. Open-top designs for mainpulating field temperature in high-latitude ecosystems. Global Change Biology 3 (suppl. 1): 20-32.
These authors evaluated 4 different chamber designs under field conditions, examining many variables but focusing on temperature differences between the inside and outside of the chambers, and unintended ecological effects. The four designs were termed “ITEX corners”, “cone chambers”, “hexagon chambers”, and “plastic tent”. There were 6 field sites, 5 in the Arctic from Sweden to Canada, and 1 in Antarctica.
This paper represents one of the outcomes of a meeting that established the International Tundra Experiment (ITEX); at this meeting a list of requirements for long-term temperature manipulation devices was constructed, leading to these 4 designs and a requirement to measure ecological effects such as changes in snow accumulation or melting.
The results were fairly consistent across chamber designs. In general, open-top chambers cause fewer and less severe ecological side-effects than closed designs, but warm the surface of the soil by 1-2 degrees compared with up to 10 or 15 degrees for some closed designs. Side-effects of the open-top chambers included some shading and interception of PAR by the chamber materials, changes in moisture concentrations in the air immediately above the soil surface (though these may have been driven by changes in temperature), and the possibility of interference from animals, such as nutrient addition by birds perching on the chambers. However, CO2 concentrations were not affected by chambers.
One of these authors, GHR Henry, will be working with me this summer at Alexandra Fjord; this was also one of the study sites in this paper.
These authors evaluated 4 different chamber designs under field conditions, examining many variables but focusing on temperature differences between the inside and outside of the chambers, and unintended ecological effects. The four designs were termed “ITEX corners”, “cone chambers”, “hexagon chambers”, and “plastic tent”. There were 6 field sites, 5 in the Arctic from Sweden to Canada, and 1 in Antarctica.
This paper represents one of the outcomes of a meeting that established the International Tundra Experiment (ITEX); at this meeting a list of requirements for long-term temperature manipulation devices was constructed, leading to these 4 designs and a requirement to measure ecological effects such as changes in snow accumulation or melting.
The results were fairly consistent across chamber designs. In general, open-top chambers cause fewer and less severe ecological side-effects than closed designs, but warm the surface of the soil by 1-2 degrees compared with up to 10 or 15 degrees for some closed designs. Side-effects of the open-top chambers included some shading and interception of PAR by the chamber materials, changes in moisture concentrations in the air immediately above the soil surface (though these may have been driven by changes in temperature), and the possibility of interference from animals, such as nutrient addition by birds perching on the chambers. However, CO2 concentrations were not affected by chambers.
One of these authors, GHR Henry, will be working with me this summer at Alexandra Fjord; this was also one of the study sites in this paper.
Mastepanov et al. 2008
Mastepanov M, Sigsgaard C, Dlugokencky EJ, Houweling S, Strom L, Tamstorf MP, Christensen TR. 2008. Large tundra methane burst during onset of freezing. Nature 456: 628-631.
These authors describe a large emission of methane from a wet tundra site in the Greenland High Arctic, which occurred in late autumn and early winter as the ground froze. This burst of methane emission is of a similar magnitude to the total methane emission from this site during the growing season, and accounts for the previously observed “shoulder” of methane in autumn at high altitudes.
The site is Zackenberg Valley, in the north-east of Greenland at about 74ºN latitude. This site appears to be broadly similar to other High Arctic tundra meadows such as Truelove Lowlands (Devon Island) and Alexandra Fjord (Ellesmere Island) and large parts of northern Russia, with an active layer 20 to 100 cm thick. The growing season measurements here were similar to previous years, and similar to another study in Siberia.
These measurements were made using an automated methane-only laser-based system, that took readings of methane flux every hour, with a data-gathering time of 1 second. Late-season pulses of methane were not observed at lower-latitude sites, possibly because a deeper permafrost “floor” allows methane to diffuse down to deeper soil layers rather than being forced upwards. Spatial and temporal variablity of the freezing methane emissions were very high, suggesting the diffusion paths of methane squeezed out of the soil were dependent upon plant root systems and similar structures.
This paper is the reason my field season at Alexandra Fjord in 2009 may extend as late as August 25 (planned) or September 10 (worst-case scenario). The figures in this paper imply the difference between measured and modeled methane emissions became apparent approximately in late August.
These authors describe a large emission of methane from a wet tundra site in the Greenland High Arctic, which occurred in late autumn and early winter as the ground froze. This burst of methane emission is of a similar magnitude to the total methane emission from this site during the growing season, and accounts for the previously observed “shoulder” of methane in autumn at high altitudes.
The site is Zackenberg Valley, in the north-east of Greenland at about 74ºN latitude. This site appears to be broadly similar to other High Arctic tundra meadows such as Truelove Lowlands (Devon Island) and Alexandra Fjord (Ellesmere Island) and large parts of northern Russia, with an active layer 20 to 100 cm thick. The growing season measurements here were similar to previous years, and similar to another study in Siberia.
These measurements were made using an automated methane-only laser-based system, that took readings of methane flux every hour, with a data-gathering time of 1 second. Late-season pulses of methane were not observed at lower-latitude sites, possibly because a deeper permafrost “floor” allows methane to diffuse down to deeper soil layers rather than being forced upwards. Spatial and temporal variablity of the freezing methane emissions were very high, suggesting the diffusion paths of methane squeezed out of the soil were dependent upon plant root systems and similar structures.
This paper is the reason my field season at Alexandra Fjord in 2009 may extend as late as August 25 (planned) or September 10 (worst-case scenario). The figures in this paper imply the difference between measured and modeled methane emissions became apparent approximately in late August.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
